There’s something special about coming home to Green Bay for the holidays. You get to catch up with old friends, visit family, revisit your favorite hometown spots, and grab a drink somewhere that hasn’t changed since you were 21. (In the best possible way, of course.)

And if there’s one thing Green Bay knows how to do, it’s a good dive bar. The kind of place with cheap drinks and a bartender who might know your life story before you finish your first beer. Fancy cocktails and trendy decor have their place, but sometimes you just want that classic Wisconsin dive bar feeling.

So, where are the best dive bars in Green Bay?

We went to the people who know Green Bay best: our local residents! In the latest installment of our Ask a Local series, we asked Green Bay locals to share their favorite dive bars. And, like true Wisconsinites, they were more than happy to share!

First, What Exactly Is a Dive Bar?

Before we get into the recommendations, let's establish what we're looking for. After all, a dive bar is a special kind of place, and not every bar with a cheap beer makes the cut.

As always, our locals say it best. Green Bay Reddit user NtGiL_29 gave us a pretty thorough breakdown of what makes a dive:

"To me, a dive bar usually fulfills several of the following criteria, but it certainly doesn't have to fulfill all:

  • Wood panel walls

  • A minimal number of taps, usually under six

  • Cheap drafts/bottles/cans of domestics, say $2.50 bottles of Coors Light

  • No commercial kitchen - bagged snacks and frozen pizza only for food

  • Eclectic decor. This could be Christmas lights up all year round, license plates all over the walls, even 80s-era Packers posters

  • A lingering cigarette smell from the bartender's last smoke break

  • A tight enough footprint that you have room for some two-top tables, but not four-top. Depending on the size of the bar, perhaps about 1,200 square feet

  • A bartender that knows the regulars by first name, knows intimate details about their lives, and is not afraid to learn about your life on your first visit

  • Bathrooms that are single-stall

  • Located in/on the edge of a residential area"

Another Green Bay Reddit user, SmolieWolie, offered another take: "A dive bar to me has a slightly shabby, unkempt look to it with great deals on food or drinks and a really diverse crowd. Usually the atmosphere is more comfortable and welcoming, with lots of regulars and people who aren't afraid to talk to someone they don't know."

So, there you have it. A little rough around the edges, a lot of character, and always room for one more. Now, let's get to the good stuff.

A man smiling, holding a drink in one hand, and giving a thumbs up with the other. He is sitting at a bar and wearing a sweatshirt that says "Jilly Jilly".

(📸 Jills Bar)

Jill's Bar

If there's one name that came up again and again when we asked locals about their favorite Green Bay dive bars, it's Jill's Bar.

"Now Jill's, THAT'S a dive bar," said Reddit user thrill316. "It might be the town's oldest dive bar. I love it."

Jill's has been around since 1981, so it's certainly earned its place as a local favorite. And if you need more convincing, Lisa from Green Bay had a pretty enthusiastic response when asked about her favorite dive:

"Jills!!!!

JILLS

JILLS JILLS"

She also shared a little more about what makes the bar so special:

"The bar has been around forever, the locals are great, the decor has really not changed since the bar was opened, as far as I know. The owners are friendly and cool, the bartenders are nice, and they have really good free popcorn every day, and karaoke every Friday and Saturday. It feels kind of like drinking in your grandparents' basement in the best possible way."

We can't think of a better endorsement for a dive bar than "feels like drinking in your grandparents' basement." Add free popcorn and weekend karaoke, and we're sold.

Lenny's Tap

Coming in as another local favorite is Lenny's Tap. This one had quite the enthusiastic following among the people we asked.

"LENNY'S!" said Reddit user Handcuffsandwhiskey.

"I'm a big fan of Lenny's Tap," added Reddit user lulubellauren12.

And Reddit user OdaDdaT shared, "Played football with Lenny's son and can't endorse it more."

We're starting to think our dive bar rating system should be based on how many people use all caps when recommending a place. By that measure, Lenny's is doing pretty well.

And really, could an endorsement get any more Green Bay than knowing the owner's family from playing football?

Hammer Inn

The Hammer Inn on State Street also earned some love from locals, with one resident giving it a particularly enthusiastic review of the food.

"I was just at the Hammer Inn on State Street for dinner, and it was one of the best burgers that I've had in a long time, and priced really well," said Green Bay local Sarah.

"Hamburger and cauliflower bits for $10.49….will definitely be back to try other things too!!"

The Pump Room

Over in Allouez, The Pump Room was another frequently mentioned local favorite.

Reddit user Internal_Swimmer3815 summed up the appeal pretty nicely:

"The Pump Room in Allouez. Super nice dude. Chill vibe. Free jukebox. Pool table. Close to home. What else does one need for a dive bar?"

That pretty much covers all the essentials!

St. Michael's Pub

"St. Michael's is definitely my local favorite!" said Reddit user NtGiL_29.

St. Michael's Pub has been holding its own in the dive bar game for more than 40 years, and it sounds like it has plenty to keep the regulars coming back. Homemade Bloody Marys, classic chili with noodles, and a game of cribbage? That's a pretty quintessential Wisconsin combination.

If you're looking for a laid-back neighborhood spot with some local history, St. Mike's deserves a spot on your list.

Chalk board with the beers that are on tap at CJ's Labor Lounge.

(📸 CJ's Labor Lounge)

CJ's Labor Lounge

Next up is CJ's Labor Lounge, described as "A true Green Bay sports bar serving cold beer and blue-collar camaraderie."

And apparently, there's another reason to stop by. Green Bay local Rebecca gave a special shout-out to Gracie the Dog, adding, "Gracie the Dog is the best assistant bartender."

We'd argue that a bar with a four-legged assistant bartender has a pretty good thing going.

C.B.'s Tap

Not to be confused with CJ's Labor Lounge, C.B.'s Tap also got a mention from locals.

With a "real 'Up North' feel," this spot is a good place to settle in for a while. Free pool and popcorn don't hurt, either. If there’s one thing we've learned from our local recommendations, it's that free snacks go a long way in earning dive bar approval.

More Green Bay Dive Bars Worth Checking Out

Of course, our locals had plenty more recommendations to share. A few other names that came up in the conversation include:

  • Simonet's

  • The Avenue

  • Some Place Else

  • Party Line

  • Cheri's Place

  • Blue Collar

  • Whiskey Rose Saloon

  • Boehmer's Bar

Interior of Shoots Bar and Grill with an LED Shoots Bar and Grill sign, Christmas lights hanging from the ceiling, and a pole from the ceiling to floor.

  • Shoots

  • BB's Bar

Your Green Bay Dive Bar Tour Awaits

Whether you're coming back to Green Bay for Thanksgiving, Christmas, or just a long overdue visit with friends, sometimes the best way to catch up is over a drink at an old-school neighborhood bar. Wherever you end up, you'll get a little taste of the local Green Bay community, and maybe even make a few new friends along the way. Just don’t forget to bring cash!