The Ultimate Green Bay Pizza Trail

The Ultimate Green Bay Pizza Trail

Since we’re all about cheese, you better believe the pizzas around here are out of this world. Here are just a few of the best Green Bay pizza spots to check out while you’re visiting!

Glass Nickel Pizza Co.

This local pizza chain got its start in the state capital of Madison and is now in nine different locations throughout Wisconsin. Each season, they put out a limited menu of favorites, or you can order off the permanent menu of specialty pizzas like the Boaris Karloff (featuring three different Boar’s Head® meats) or the Portabella Lugosi. They also have a Daiya® Delight pizza for those who are vegan or lactose-intolerant! Don’t feel like pizza? Glass Nickel Pizza Co. also has pasta, salad, chicken, and shrimp on the menu.

Happy Joe’s

Ask anyone who spent their childhood in Green Bay and they’ll have stories about Happy Joe’s. They have a playroom with arcade games for the kids (and the kids at heart), a viewing window where you can watch your pizza being made, and a wide selection of signature pizzas that will satisfy any craving. The whole Discover Green Bay crew is obsessed with the Taco Joe pizza, but you really can’t go wrong with any of the options on their menu! You can place an order for delivery or takeout, or you can dine in as well. This is also a great spot for large group gathers around some pizzas!

Heartland Pizza Company

If you love wood fired pizzas, you will love Heartland Pizza Company. This restaurant has only been around a few years, but they’ve already become a favorite in the Green Bay pizza scene. The dough for their crust takes several days to make, and you can really taste the difference. The sauces are all made from scratch, as well as the ice cream they churn in-house using local milk. Their menu is extensive, vegan-friendly, and absolutely mouthwatering!

Parker John’s BBQ & Pizza

If you can’t decide between BBQ and pizza, Parker John’s is the place for you! Start with an order of the Sconnie fries for your appetizer, then see if you have what it takes to take down one of their massive pizzas. If you’re truly torn on what to order, you can’t go wrong with the Triple P Pizza. This is a pulled pork pizza that combines their finger-licking BBQ with their signature sauce, then covered in melted Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella cheese.

Sammy’s Pizza

If your idea of a really good pizza starts with a time-tested, traditional family recipe, you will love what Sammy’s Pizza has to offer. The dough, sauce, and sausage at this popular Green Bay pizza restaurant have not changed since 1958. The pasta is hand-made in house on a vintage Italian pasta machine and their six signature pasta sauces are all Crispigna family recipes.

Strada Pizzeria

Strada Pizzeria is another newcomer to the Green Bay pizza scene. They opened their doors in De Pere in 2020, but don’t let that fool you. Their Italian street pizzas are all based in tradition. The crust is made with dough that has fermented for 72 hours to enhance the flavor and texture. Stop in and grab a medium or large pie, or you can order by the slice—a great way to try several different varieties!

Alright, who’s hungry? We can’t wait to hear which of these Green Bay pizza spots is your favorite. Order or download the latest Destination Guide and start planning your trip to Greater Green Bay!

About the Author

Blogs By Category

Also featured in the Blog
Veg out in Green Bay

Ready to “Veg Out” in Greater Green Bay?

While Green Bay vegetarian restaurants are admittedly few and far between, there are some truly craveable vegetarian dishes that you MUST try while you’re here. We promise they’re so good, they’ll win over even the most passionate meat-lovers you know.

Full Blog »
Oneida Nation Cultural Village

Green Bay History: More Than Just a Football Team

The history of Green Bay is a fascinating story that includes nearly 10,000 years of Indiginous settlement, French fur trading, farming, shipping, and a papermaking industry that still thrives today. Oh, and of course, the formation of the greatest football team of all time.

Full Blog »
Plae Burger

Must-Try Burgers in Green Bay

It should come as no surprise to you that the land of tailgating culture knows a thing or two about burgers. There really is nothing better than sinking your teeth into a big, juicy hamburger!

Full Blog »
Can't Miss Green Bay Fall Events

Can’t Miss Fall Events in Green Bay!

Plan an unforgettable autumn adventure in Green Bay! As the leaves change colors, we are looking forward to raising a stein, harvesting our grapes, enjoying caramel apples and hitting the pumpkin patch.

Full Blog »
A Guide to Green Bay Bars and Nightlife

A Guide to Green Bay Bars & Nightlife

Greater Green Bay has some of the best bars in the Midwest, and no, we’re not just saying that. There’s something for everyone here, from the friendliest neighborhood taverns to a bar designed just for dogs (yes, really).

Full Blog »